Israel Letters
Dear Family and Friends,
I am sorry
many of you have not heard from me in a long time. Each time I sit down to
write to you, I try to think of cheerful, upbeat things to write about, but it
is hard to be upbeat when your heart is breaking and you feel paralyzed by fear.
Today and
tomorrow I will attend more funerals. I will express my condolences to more
grieving relatives in more Shiva houses. Worst of all, I will look into
the eyes of my children and see confusion, anger, fear and a mature sadness no
child should ever know. My neighbors and I will talk in quiet, strained voices
and ask each other, How can we change things? Why doesn't anyone seem to care?
When Hitler,
yemach shemo, was exterminating the Jews of Europe, the world, along with most
Jews, remained silent. As a child growing up in the Hebrew Academy of Cleveland,
I heard my teachers, many of whom were Holocaust survivors, try to make some
sense of this. They would say that no one knew what was going on. That no
one outside Europe could imagine or accept the horror of what was going on.
That the Jews in North America were afraid of the consequences should they
call too much attention to themselves or to the fact that they identified with a
people on foreign soil. Some American Jews deluded themselves into
believing it was not those people's Jewishness that lead to their deaths, but
rather their supposed affiliation with communism, orbolshevicism or some other
political -ism. So most people wrung their hands and sighed and said oh
dear; and six million men, women and children from all walks of life and all
religious and political philosophies were murdered.
Everyday in
Israel Jewish men, women and children are being murdered. Not because of where
in Israel we live, or what we believe, or how we express those beliefs
politically or religiously. We are being murdered because we are Jews. The
Arabs, the media, the political spin-doctors and some members of the Israeli
government would have you believe differently. They will tell you that it is
politics, or economics, or settlements, or entitlements, or refugees. I beg you,
do not believe this.
It is said that in every generation another evildoer rises up to destroy the
Jewish people. Haman, Hilter, Arafat, yemach shemam: all the same. Arafat and
the Arabs want us dead. Are you listening? It has nothing to do with
history or geopolitics. The PLO was founded in 1964, three years before Israel
captured Judea, Samaria and Gaza. Their purpose was to get rid of the Jews. The
names have changed, but the goal remains the same.
Jews are being murdered every day here. My children are angry and afraid.
Yitzchak (age 13) lost one of his closest friends a few weeks ago: a boy his
age, brutally murdered by Arabs, his body so badly mutilated positive
identification was made only through fingerprints. Shoshana (age 9)has
nightmares, especially the nights before the days that I travel to Jerusalem to
work. Rivka (age 16) commutes to Jerusalem for school. She was evacuated
from Jerusalem’s central bus station last Friday during a bomb scare. Several
times the buses she has been traveling in have been fired upon. She
suffers from headaches and fatigue; the doctor say it’s stress. Ariella, (age
4) asks me to promise I’ll come home each time I go to work.
Many of you write or call to express
concern, and I appreciate it. But we have reached a point where that is
not enough. We, here in Israel, are on the front lines. We are facing an
enemy determined to kill us or drive us out of Israel ENTIRELY. Read that part
again. This is not about the territories. This is not about
settlements. This is not even about Jerusalem. This is about the People of
Israel being driven out of the Land of Israel, the WHOLE land. This is about
Arabs murdering Jews. That's it. That's the whole deal. Straightforward. Simple.
Final.
Now you know. So what are you going to do about it? I remember during the '67
and '73 wars, how we in the U.S. marched in the streets in support of Israel.
We wrote letters to members of Congress, we called radio stations, we
signed petitions. We prayed in private and we prayed in public. Using every
means we could think of we tried to communicate two ideas: we supported the
State of Israel and WE WERE NOT PREPARED TO SIT IDLY BY WHILE JEWS WERE DYING.
So, where are you? What have you done today to save my life and the lives of my
children? I keep asking myself, why are things different now than in '67 and
'73? Where is all the noise?
It occurs to
me that the big difference now is that Jews outside Israel are confused by the
dissension in the ranks of the Israeli government. They hear government
ministers blaming different sectors of the Israeli populace for our troubles.
Its the leftists! It’s the right-wingers! It’s the secularists! It’s the
ultra-orthodox! It’s the Tel-Aviv yuppies! Its the settlers! So people
think this is a political issue, and the Government of Israel should handle it.
Well, right now they are handling it by letting Jews die. There seems to
be this message coming from the government that if Israel does everything the
U.S. wants it to do, the U.S. will realize that we are the good guys and the
Arabs are the bad guys and then the U.S. will somehow force Arafat and the Arabs
to uphold the agreements they've already signed. Do you think the U.S. would be
pressuring Arafat this way if they thought American Jews cared? Do you think the
Israeli government would give in so easily if they thought the same thing?
Listen people, I am not some anonymous
columnist with a political ax to grind and a publication deadline. This is me,
Esther, and I am speaking to you with all my heart. Jews are dying. I am
afraid. What are you going to do about it? Please help us.
Love,
Esther
maymail@netvision.net.il
*********************************************************
This could be a letter from Yakov "Kobi" Mandel, 14 years old, while
he is now waiting for the Chevra Kadisha to finish 'preparing him' for his
burial in one hour here in Kfar Etzion cemetery.
Dear Friends around the World:
Most of you don't know me. I'm just an 8th grader in Israel learning in
Efrat's Jr. High School. I used to be alive in Tekoah where my family
moved to from Efrat. My father works at Aish Hatorah in the Old
City. I was born in the USA. I had my brit milah in the
USA. As I grew up, we moved to Israel. I had my bar mitzvah last
year in Israel. It was fun and my relatives joined me and my family for
this simcha. I have an American passport and an Israeli passport.
How lucky to have two passports.
Yesterday as a Jewish kid, I went with my friend to the nearby Nachal Hartin,
not far from my home in Tekoah. I was killed with my friend by a bunch of
Arabs with stones and rocks. They pummeled my head into obliteration
so that even the Chevra Kadisha who is working on my body now for my burial
could not really recognize me from my bar mitzvah pictures. Before I get wrapped
in my father's talit, a talit that I was wrapped in at my brit milah in
preparation for my burial, I wanted to leave some notes for some people
TO Prime Minister Sharon: We kids in the 8th grade ran
around the cities for you with bumper stickers and banners because you promised
me security and safety if you were elected. So far, you have broken your
promise. I realized that you are responding much tougher than Mr. Barak
when we Jewish kids are blown up or killed. Please do what you can
so my younger sister and brother stay alive to say kaddish for me and perhaps
name their future newborn after me.
TO Yossi Beilin and Yossi Sarid: We kids in the 8th grade never met
you two characters. I was told by the adults that you still believe
in peace partners who kill and maim kids intentionally. I was told
by the adults that you are still against us 'settler kids.' Why did you
give the PLO
arms over the last years? I think if I were to have lived and become
a lawyer, I would try you two for treason and send you to jail. Can't you
two understand that we Jewish kids are being killed like in the 1940's because
we are Jewish not because we live in ''settlements." Did you both
know that Tel Aviv University campus today was once an Arab village called Sheik
Musah in Tel Aviv? Why don't you want to give back Tel Aviv University ?
Jewish kids who were killed over the last 9months were killed in Holon, Kfar
Saba, Tel Aviv and other cities. Are Arabs killing the Jewish kids there
because those are settlements? Or, maybe they were settlements in the
1940's.
TO President Bush: I am an American citizen too. When I used
to go to NY to visit my grandparents, your officials at JFK used to check my
American passport and not my Israeli passport. This summer I can't be
checked anymore at JFK, so your officials will have one less Jewish kid to deal
with. I know that you are tougher than Mr. Clinton was as was your
father. I don't understand as I was reading last night that you and your
government were 'upset' about settlements. Do you really think I am about
to be buried because of a settlement? Please wake up, it is 58 years after
Hitler. I was brutally murdered last night because I am a JEW JEW
JEW JEW!
Please tell Mr. Powell to stop trying to be a politician and remember that he
was a decorated soldier who did so much to help my country of Israel and the USA
during the GULF WAR.
TO Mom and Dad: What can I say, except that I am sorry that you are now
crying. I did not see you cry too much growing up. May be you cried
when my brit milah was going on and you were giving me my name, Yakov. All
that wood that stored up outside the house for tomorrow night's LAG Ba'omer
bonfire will not be used by me and my dead friend. I guess you and the
other kids won't be having any bonfire as you sit shiva for me. I will
think about you when I meet G-d tonight and I want to thank you for your nonstop
giving and caring for me. I will miss you and the others in the
family. I am sorry I did not make my bed yesterday or clean up my room. I
wish I still have time, but the hearse is here to carry me in your talit to my
final resting place.
Love,
Yakov
a 14 year old,
Born in the USA, Murdered in Israel
Reality Check by Harvey Tannenbaum on the funeral route Efrat, Israel (A Jew,
not a Settler)