Main >> Cultures & Beliefs >> Judaism

 
Shmirat Halashon

Shmirat Halashon

     "When you have spoken the word, it reigns over you. When  it is unspoken you reign over it."

***********************

 

Click to View or Add Text.

See a Daily Shmirat Halashon halachah!

***********************

Guard Your Tongue by Rabbi Pliskin

***********************

Repentance for Speaking Lashon Hara

                 (by Ellen Solomon, on Torah.org)

                                  Repentance, or Teshuva, involves three steps (in any order):

      (1) Regretting one's actions
      (2) Confessing the misdeed privately to G-d
      (3) Committing to not repeat the error in the future

                  In addition, any sin one person commits against another also requires rectification:

      (4) make amends or repay the damages
      (5) ask for forgiveness

If someone spoke Lashon Hara, all five of the steps are required.  The first three are the same as in all repentance - sincere regret, confessional prayer, and the resolve plus strategies to avoid speaking
it in the future.

To make amends, the speaker must go back to all those who heard his Lashon Hara and explain to them that what he said was incorrect.  He must also apologize to the subject of the Lashon Hara and ask for forgiveness.  If, however, the speaker is certain that the Lashon Hara was never accepted, he is only required to complete steps 1-3.

Note: if, as part of asking forgiveness, telling the subject about the Lashon Hara would cause the subject more anguish (either because he is hearing it for the first time or it renews his distress over the matter), the speaker is forbidden to mention it.  Instead he should tell the subject that he sinned against him without specifying how, and ask his forgiveness.

***********************

Ahavas  Yisroel by Shulamis Lifshitz  -new!!

***********************

Enter the Forum!

 

***********************

Giving the Benefit of the Doubt (source sheet)

***********************

TOP TEN TIPS FOR HEALING WITH WORDS

Bite your tongue before you gossip; your tongue will hurt, but your friends won't.
Stop yourself from gossiping by changing the subject mid-sentence; only you will notice.
Never say derogatory things about yourself; people might agree with you.
Never use humor to put others down; joking around usually comes around.
Speak sweetly, so if you have to eat your words, they won't taste so bad.
The gossip game always takes turns; the only way to avoid being "it" is to stop playing.
Trust makes a friendship; gossip takes it away.
You are the proud owner of a set of ears; use them at your own discretion.
To get friends who won't gossip about you, you must be a friend who won't gossip about them.

Stamp out gossip by voting with your feet; just walk away if someone gossips.                                   

The Torah states, "And (the one afflicted with tzora'as) shall call out: 'Unclean, Unclean'" (Leviticus 13:45). The afflicted person, as he moves about, calls this out about himself as a warning to others.

The Sheloh HaKodesh, a revered commentary, writes that one can also read the verse in another manner. It could be that the afflicted person is calling out ABOUT other people, "Unclean! Unclean!" That is a person who finds fault with others is really projecting his own faults and imperfections onto others. As the Sages say in the Talmud (tractate of Kiddushin, page 70a), "Those who try to invalidate others do so with their own blemishes."

One means of finding out your own faults is to see what faults you tend to notice in others. When one points a finger at someone, three fingers point back at himself!

                                                by Rabbi Zelig Pliskin 

***********************

Chofetz Chaim's Lesson a Day

Days 1-25

Days 26-61

***********************

Elul Contemplations

***********************

Mishmeret Hours:

 Most of us control something in our lives, whether it be the food that we eat, or the TV and movies that we watch, or even the music that we listen to. In these areas, we are extremely stringent and refuse to compromise them. But one area that many of us may be lax in is shemiras haloshon. That's what the mishmeret hours are; you choose the hours that you will not speak loshon hora and keep in mind for that hour that you are not speaking loshon hora and B'Zchut Cholim that you know of will have refuah. By practicing restraint during that hour or to that you don't speak loshon hora you are giving yourself an exercise in how to help guard your tongue from evil talk. TIZKU LMITZVOT!!!!

To sign up for your own  Mishmeret Hours, please e-mail me: Cling2treeoflife@aol.com

***********************

The 7 conditions to satisfy before speaking L"H

(1) The speaker must have witnessed the incident himself, rather than knowing about it from rumor.  (If he has only heard about the incident, then he must verify its authenticity firsthand.)


(2) The speaker should reflect thoroughly, not hastily concluding something is theft or damage or any other offense, that the action in question is truly a violation according to halacha.


(3) The speaker should first approach the transgressor privately, and rebuke him with gentle language (such that the transgressor would be inclined to listen), because perhaps this can have an impact and inspire
the person to improve his ways.  If the transgressor does not listen, then the speaker should alert the public of the individual's guilt. (In a case where the speaker knows in advance that the transgressor won't listen to rebuke, we will discuss it IY"H in paragraph 7.)


(4) The description of the sin should not be exaggerated [for "effect" or any other reason].


(5) The speaker must have pure intentions ("to'elet," lit. "purpose"). As we will discuss later in paragraph 4, the speaker should not - Heaven forbid - enjoy his friend's (the transgressor's) disgrace, nor act out of a previous hatred he felt for the person.


(6) If the purpose of speaking the Lashon Hara (e.g. causing the sinner to repent, warning the community to stay away from such activity) can be achieved in another way rather than speaking Lashon Hara, it is forbidden to speak Lashon Hara.


(7) By speaking Lashon Hara, the transgressor should not be caused more damage than would be appropriate as determined by a court of Jewish law reviewing the case.  This is discussed in detail in Hilchot Rechilut chapter nine.  [An example would be if a thief would be obligated to repay the victim $100, but Lashon Hara caused him damages of $500.]

***********************

The heilige Chasam Sofer zt"l asks, "We do not understand why Miriam had to be niftar in the midbar and was not zoche to enter Eretz Yisroel."  He replies, "We can say that Miriam was niftar because of the loshon hora which she spoke to Aharon about her brother Moshe Rabeinu.  After Miriam was niftar, there was no longer a be'er (be'erah shel Miriam).  For water, Moshe Rabeinu had to hit the stone and as a result, Moshe and Aharon were niftar in the midbar, too.  We can learn from this how terrible loshon hora is.  Because of the loshon hora which Miriam spoke, Moshe Rabeinu, Aharon Hakohen and Miriam were all niftar in the midbar.  Based upon this, we can say that when Chazal tell us that loshon hora kills three people, that is a remez to Moshe, Aharon and Miriam.

"Mee ha'ish he'chofetz chaim ohev yamim l'ros tov... n'tzor l'shoncha mei'ra".  The roshei teivos of "N'tzor L'shoncha Mei'ra" is b'gematria one hundred and twenty.  This is meramez that if one is careful not to speak loshon hora he will be zoche to live a full hundred and twenty years, gezunterheit!

***********************

poems

Be careful what you say

What are you saying; are your words good or bad,

Positive or negative, happy or sad?

The words of your mouth lead to failure or success.

Do you ever wonder how you got into that mess?

You are in charge of the words that you speak.

Will you be strong, or will you be weak?

Do you speak words of sickness, or words of health?

Do you speak of poverty, or are your words of wealth?

What you say each day is what comes to pass in your life.

Are your days full of peace, or are they full of strife?

Your life will reflect the words that you say.

Speak positive, uplifting words and life will manifest that way.

Speak negative, depressing, 'Oh, poor me' kind of things...

Then the road to failure is what these words will bring.

It's your choice; it's up to you.

What are you saying; what will you do?


--Heather Naomi Pierpoint

*************************************************************************

My Weapon

Each day I come out, ready for war

Armed with my gear, my weapon

This weapon is powerful, mighty and tough

For it can kill and threaten

 

I use it quite often, against enemies

And they are left shaken with fright

And so I'm prepared for every battle

Because of the weapon I own to fight

 

My weapon is flexible, so very fragile

Yet it can target so strong

This weapon is popular, for everyone has it

But some use this weapon quite wrong

 

I mastered the skill of aiming my weapon

At an age so small and young

But it takes many years to improve the aim

For the weapon is my harmful tongue

*********************************************************

Gossip

It 

topples

Governments,

Wrecks

Marriages,

Ruins

Careers,

Busts

Reputations.

Causes

Heartaches,

Nightmares,

Indigestion.

Spawns Suspicion,

Generates 

Grief,

Dispatches

Innocent

People

To cry in their pillows.

Even its name

Hisses.

It's called

Gossip.

Office Gossip

Shop Gossip

Party Gossip

It makes 

Headlines

and Headaches.

Before

you repeat

A story,

Ask yourself:

Is it true?

Is it fair?

Is it necessary?

If not,

Hush up!

************************

The Shmirat Halashon Forum-express yourself!

***********************

The "Reverse Gossip" Game

Gossip is one of the world's most destructive habits, and
we're exposed to it practically everywhere we go - work,
recreation, sports, home, in magazines, on television, etc. There is absolutely nothing beneficial about gossip - it hurts EVERYONE involved.

There's a term for it in Hebrew; it's called "Loshon Hora" (Loshon = Tongue, Hora = evil). Loshon hora, or gossip, is the same whether speaking it or listening to it. What's more, it's still Loshon Hora even if what we say about a person is true! And, despite the instant gratification it may bring (isn't it fun?), it will not make the person we are sharing this with, trust us any deeper.

They will subconsciously be thinking, "Hmm, I wonder what he/she says about me when I'm not there." It certainly will not help in the WINNING WITHOUT INTMIDATION process. So, let's try something different.

The name of our new game is, "The Reverse Gossip Game." In this game, instead of telling people the gossip people say about them or others, let's repeat only the good that people say (even if we have to "suggest" that good), and find reasons to judge others favorably in all other situations. Let's say John speaks negatively about Mary. For example.

John: Mary is really lazy.

You: I've never noticed that. She is talented, wouldn't you
agree?

John (Grudgingly): Yes, I guess so.

Later you see Mary at the coffee machine and the
conversation goes as follows:

You: I was talking with John earlier. He was saying you are very talented (after all, he did agree to that, didn't he?).

Mary: Wow! I didn't know he thought that of me. I've always
felt he was very judgmental and snobby.

You: Hmm, never picked up on that. Really hard worker, isn't he?

Mary: Well, I guess you have to give him credit for that.

The next day you and John are talking and you happen to
mention:

You: Mary was talking about how hard a worker you are.

John: Really? Didn't think she liked me, but maybe she's not so bad after all.

Now, the next time John and Mary cross paths they both see each other in an entirely different light, with a completely different attitude and set of expectations - one of peace, enjoyment, and kindness. And it all happened because of you. You don't feel as though you've manipulated them, do you? There are people who might feel that way.

Interesting, isn't it? It's perfectly acceptable to repeat
the bad and cause trouble, but to help along (positively
persuade) the good and create peace between people may be looked at in a negative way. I don't think so. Creating peace is never a negative concept. And if anyone tells you it is... please don't believe them. Instead, find something good about them. Then tell someone else.

- Bob Burg ( http://www.burg.com ) speaks on "Endless
Referrals" and "Positive Persuasion." He is author of
"Endless Referrals: Network Your Everyday Contacts Into
Sales" and "Winning Without Intimidation: The Art of
Positive Persuasion."

***********************

The Gossiper 

A woman repeated a bit of gossip about a neighbor. Within a few days the whole community knew the story. The person it concerned was deeply hurt and offended. Later the woman responsible for spreading the rumor learned that it was completely untrue. She was very sorry and went to a wise old sage to find out what she could do to repair the damage. 

"Go to the marketplace," he said, "and purchase a chicken, and have it killed. Then on your way home, pluck its feathers and drop them one by one along the road." Although surprised by this advice, the woman did what she was told. 

The next day the wise man said, "Now go and collect all those feathers you dropped yesterday and bring them back to me." 

The woman followed the same road, but to her dismay, the wind had blown the feathers all away. After searching for hours, she returned with only three in her hand. "You see," said the old sage, "it's easy to drop them, but it's impossible to get them back. So it is with gossip. It doesn't take much to spread a rumor, but once you do, you can never completely undo the wrong." 

Author Unknown


"Chicken Soup for the Teenage Soul" Editor: Jack Canfield, Mark Victor Hansen and Kimberly Kirberger

***********************

The Shmirat Halashon Forum-express yourself!

***********************

Lashon Hara

    When we learn in sifrei kodesh {holy books} that reward will be taken or given to us if we do or don't do certain acts, it's not simple to explain that Hashem takes away our merit for acts that we've done or that He gives us merit for acts that we haven't done. How could that be fair judgment?! Rather, in terms of Lashon Hara, when we speak L"H we dull our spiritual senses and are less inclined to perform mitzvot (How do you feel when you perform an aveirah {sin}? Like you are a member of the Am HaNivchar {Chosen People} and you want to rush out and serve God?! Of course not! You feel as if you have pushed yourself away from Hashem and that He wouldn't want you to serve Him! [Which is not true, but that's still how we feel.]). Furthermore, since Judaism sensitizes a person to life and to the emotions of others, if one speaks L"H, one becomes less sensitive and therefore one's ability to care and relate to others, specifically through mitzvot, is diminished.

***********************

From the Heart...
=================

Last week we discussed Loshan Hora, tale-bearing, slander and gossip.  This weeks Parsha speaks about how we should approach another person if we feel the need to point out some aspect of their behavior that is bothering us or may seem unacceptable.

The Baal Shem Tov tells us that another person is like a mirror - if we find ourselves noticing faults in others, it is because they exist within ourselves. It is not such a foreign concept - it is common in psychological terms to speak of one person 'projecting' their own faults onto another.  It is incumbent upon us to realize that when we see a fault in somebody else, it is only because we need to work on ourselves.

This fits well with the time-period we are in, Sefiras Haomer.  During this traditional period of semi-mourning, we commemorate the loss of Rabbi Akiva's 24,000 disciples.  The Torah tells us that each of them was so sure that he was right, and so determined to share this wonderful news with his fellow, that he lost sight of his fellow's needs and wishes.

It is said that "Words that come from the heart, enter the heart."  If the other person is not receptive to my message, this is a clear indication that my words are not coming from 'the right place' - the blame falls upon me, rather than upon them.  If I still need to point something out to somebody, it must be done in a manner of sincere and genuine kindness and concern for them, not for myself.

Our tradition is replete with anecdotes regarding the importance of guarding one's speech.  The story is told of the group of travelers who found themselves guests in a stranger's house, in a strange city, their
host being kind enough to feed them and provide shelter.  The guests, scrupulous in their observance of the kosher laws, asked question after question regarding the exact details of the food and its preparation.  One of those present in the house asked them, "Tell me - are you as careful about what comes out of your mouth as you are as what goes into it?"

The tongue has no bones.  This allows it to move in any direction.  We have to be careful that it should only move in the right direction!


=======================================================
taken from this WEBSITE:  www.weeklytorah.com

To add yourself or a friend to this list, send e-mail to
subscribe@weeklytorah.
***********************

 Parshas Tazria

By Rabbi Zev Leef


Life and Death in the Hands of the Tongue

 
Remember what Hashem, your God, did to Miriam on the way when you left Egypt (Devarim 24:9) Almost all of Tazria and most of Metzora are concerned with the intricate laws of tzora'as.  Tzora'as afflicted people as a consequence of having spoken lashon hara.  This is hinted to in Ki Seitzei, where the Torah warns us to be careful with respect to the laws of tzora'as and immediately thereafter to remember Miriam's punishment in the desert for speaking lashon hara about her brother Moshe.  Miriam was immediately afflicted with tzora'as and forced to leave the encampment for seven days. It seems paradoxical that the Torah chose to admonish us not to speak about the faults and shortcomings of others by reminding us of Miriam's sin.
 
During the entire time Miriam was afflicted, the nation did not travel.  The whole nation waited for her as a consequence of the merit she accrued by waiting to see what would happen to her three-month old brother Moshe when she placed him into the Nile in a basket (Sotah 9b).  Again we wonder: What benefit was it to Miriam to have the entire Jewish people delayed for her sake.  Did that waiting not highlight the cause of her banishment?  Would it not have been better for Miriam for the nation to proceed, unaware of her sin?
 
The answer is that Miriam did not sin.  Her intentions in speaking about Moshe were completely well-intentioned, without any malice.  She meant no harm to her beloved brother; nor did she cause Moshe any harm, or even ill-feeling.  Despite this she was stricken with tzora'as.  Her disease was not a punishment but rather the inevitable, natural result of lashon hara.  Because she had not sinned, Moshe did not pray for forgiveness for Miriam - only that she be healed.
 
The command to remember Miriam does not denigrate her, for she committed no intentional sin.  But we do learn from that act of rememberance the devastating effect of lashon hara, even when spoken unintentionally and without malice.  Just as it makes no difference if one swallows poison intentionally or unintentionally, so, too, lashon hara devastates us, even when spoken without deliberate malice.
 
To highlight the intrinsic devastation wrought by lashon hara, it had to be crystal clear that Miriam did not sin and that her intentions were in fact pure.  Miriam exhibited her love for Moshe when she waited anxiously to see what would happen to him.  The waiting of the nation for her was a reminder of her earlier waiting and, at the same time, the proof that she had acted without malice towards Moshe.  As Rambam in Hilchos Tumas Tzira'as (16:10) writes:
 
...Concerning this the Torah warns us to be careful with tzora'as and to remember what Hashem did to Miriam, as if to say: "Contemplate what happened to Miriam the Prophetess when she spoke against her brother' who was younger than her, whom she brought up on her lap and for whom she endangered herself when she saved him from the sea and whom she had no intention to harm.  She erred only in comparing him to the other prophets and [Moshe] did not care about what she said because [he] was a very humble person and still was immediatelhy punished with tzora's...There were two distinct aspects of the Mikdash which atoned for lashon hara.  The Gemara (Zevachim 88b) relates that both the ketores (incense) and the me'il ( the garment of the Kohen Gadol from which bells and pomegranate-like ornaments hung) atoned for lashon hara.
 
The Gemara explains that the me'il atoned for the lashon hara spoken publicly and the ketores for the lashon hara betzina (literally hidden lashon hara).  The latter is difficult to understand, however, since we learn of the ketores' ability to atone for the lashon hara from its use to stop the plague that broke out when the people blamed Moshe and Aharon for the deaths of Korach and his entourage.  That lashon hara was public.
 
Perhaps, then, the Gemara is referring to two aspects of the damage caused by lashon hara.  According to this understanding, public lashon hara refers to the harm done to the person that it was spoken against.  Hidden lashon hara refers to the spiritual damage to the speaker of the lashon hora himself, the destruction of his neshama.
 
What, then, is that spiritual destruction, which is physically manifested by tzora'as?  It is the power of speech that distinguishes man from all other creatures.  The faculty of speech enables man to fulfill his purpose in the universe.  Through speech man attaches himself to his Creator by learning and teaching Torah; through speech man addresses his Creator in prayer; through speech man crystallizes his thoughts, which in turn leads to action, as it says (Devarim 30:14), "for this mitzvah is close to you in your mouth and heart to do it;" and finally, it is speech that enables man to communicate with thers to unite in the communal service of the almighty.
 
When man uses his unique power of speech to unite the world in service of Hashem, he realizes his potential as the pinnacle of Creation.  The Hebrew word for tongue, lashon, is related to lash, the process of mixing solids and liquids together.  The tongue cakes the spiritual inner essence of the soul and expresses it in the physical realm - thereby mixing spiritual and physical together.
 
Utilizing the tongue for lashon hara, to degrade, to defile, to cause strife and dissension, divests man of the very essence of his distinction as a human being by corrupting his most exalted faculty.  The Yerushalmi says that there are three sins for which man is punished in this world and in the next - immorality, murder and idolatry - and lashon hara is equal to all three.  These three sins represent the destrution of man's physical, emotional and spiritual self.  Lashon hara equals them all.  For the totality of the human being is destroyed by the corruption of his ultimate distinction, his speech, Thus, one afflicted with lashon hara defiles like a corpse.  He is banished from society and mourns himself, for the essence of his being has been negated.
 
AT the conclusion of Shemonah Esrei we beseech Hashem, "My God, guard my tongue from evil and my lips from speaking deceitfully."  After we have used our mouths for communicating with our creator, we can fully appreciate the calamity inherent in corrupting that same wondrous instrument by using it for lashon hara.
 
The laws of childbirth precede the laws of tzora'as.  Man has the ability to be a partner in creation, to create a new being, or he can take his own body and divest it of tis Divine essence by speaking lashon hara.  Both extremes are presenged.  The choice is ours.  That is the literal intent of the words of Chazal that life and death are in the hands of tha tongue.
 

************************
Parshas Metzora
Selfishness and Narrow Vision


When you arrive in the land of Canaan that I give you as a possession, and I will place a tzora'as affliction upon a house in the land of your possession (Vayikra 14:34) The last of the various forms of tzora'as is that affecting homes.  That form of tzorz'as was unknown until Bnei Yisrael entered Eretz Yisrael.  According to Chazal, the previous inhabitants hid their valuables in the walls of their homes to prevent them from falling into the hands of the conquering Jewish army.  When the walls of these houses were subsequently struck with tzora'as, necessitating the removal of parts of its walls and, in some cases, the destruction of the entire house, these hidden treasures were discovered by the new House owners. This is extremely puzzling.  We are also told that tzora'as in the walls of homes was a punishment for selfishness.  Why should those who displayed the extremely negative characteristic of selfishness have been rewarded with the discovery of hidden treasures?
 
The Torah tells us that before the Kohen comes to inspect the suspected discoloration to determine whether there is in fact tzota'as, all the contents of the house are to be removed (Vayikra 14:35).  That way they do not become impure if the house is declared to have tzora'as.  The Midrash, however, adds another reason for removing all the vessels: it is a corrective for the selfishness which causes tzora'as in the first place.  Selfish people often pretend that they have less than they do to avoid lending others their possessions or giving tzedakah.  Having to remove all his possessions in public causes him acute embarrassment and helps to atone for and correct his selfishness.
 
The Mishnah in Nega'im (12:5), however, gives a totally different explanation of the removal of the contents from the house: Divine concern tor the property of a Jew.  Only relatively inexpensive earthenware vessels can be easily purified by immersion in a mikveh.  Nevertheless, Hashem is concerned with even this small loss, and allows the removal of all vessels before the house is declared impure.
 
One might have thought thet if the intention was to cure selfishness, a lesson on the unimportance of material possessions would be more fitting, and not one which conveys the value of every penny.
 
The truth is, however, that selfishness - literally tzorus ayin, a narrow eye - is the result of not appreciating the true value of material possesions and viewing them from a very narrow perspective.  We are taught that tzaddikim value their material possessions even more than their lives.  Thus Yaakov put his life in danger to retrieve some inexpensive earthenware vessels.
 
Earthenware is unique in that it contracts tumah, spiritual impurity, only through exposure, of the source of impurity, to its inside surface, but not through contact with the outside walls of the vessel.  Why are earthenware vessels singled out in this fashion?  The value of any vessel can be measured in two ways: in terms of the intrinsic value of the material from which it is made or in terms of its fuctional value.  The materials of an earthenware vessel have little intrinsic value.  Their utility alone gives earthenware vessels their value.  In order for something to contract ritual impurity, it must have a value.  Hence, an earthenware vessel becomes impure only through contact with its functional part - the inside - and not through contact with the materials of the outside wall.
 
A tzaddik views his material possessions as earthenware vessels - i.e., of no intrinsic value themselves, but rather deriving their importance only from their function.  Material possessions, in his view, are tools in the service of Hashem.  They may, for instance, allow him to do acts of chesed and benefit others.  Both his body and his material possessions are means to serve Hashem.  They differ only in that the body is acquired as a "birthday present'.  The acquisition of material possessions requires effort.  Thus his material possessions are more precious to the tzaddik than his own body because their acquisition required more effort.  The tzadik's perspective on possessions contrasts with the narrow perspective of the one who sees only the presonal benefit his possessions can bring him.
 
When the person whose house was afflicted with tzora'as was made aware of Hashem's concern for every Jew's material possessions, his selfish view (tzaras ayin) was challenged and the corrective process begun.  The embarrassment of being exposed to the neighbors' scrutiny was another aspect of the same process.  The removal of the vessels to the public domain hints to the fact that their purpose is not just to serve oneself.
 
The valuables hidden by the Emorim were tainted and contaminated by intense selfishness.  The Emorom hid thim to deprive the Jews from benefiting from them, even though they were doomed to lose them anyway.  In the hand of people with a tendency towards selfishness, this wealth would have been terribly detrimental.  Therefore Hashem utilized the tzora'as as a vehicle to provide the wealth in a manner designed to correct the evil of selfishness.  The victim of tzora'as was forced ro recast his attitudes towards marerial possessions prior to receiving this new bounty.
 
If one fails to learn the lesson of tzora'as afflicting the house, his selfishness will grow into haughtiness.  Then his clothes, called by Chazal the instruments of honoring a person, will be afflicted as well.  If he still does not heed the warning, he will descend yet further until he acts with total disregard for anyone but himself.  That latter attitude is manifested as lashon hara and motzi shem ra, speech designed to denigrate others.  As a punishment the perpetrator's very body will be scourged with tzora'as.
 
We can now understand what appear to be conflicting opinions regarding the deaths of the students of R' Akiva.  The Gemara (Yevamos 62b) says that they did not treat each other with respect.  The Midrash (Bereishis Rabbah 61:3) says that they exhibited tzarus ayin, selfishness, with regard to their Torah and did not share it with one another.  Torah is one's most precious possession, but it must not become a means of personal aggrandizement.  When one truly appreciates his fellow Jew and honors him, he desires to share with him his tools for service of Hashem.  In this vein, sharing one's Torah is the supreme expression of honor for one's fellow man.  Hence the two descriptions of the faults of the students of R'Akiva are in fact one.

 ***********************

Enter the Forum!


FastCounter by bCentral