|
|||||||||||
Joe Moreira's Brazilian Jiu-jitsuClick here to go back to the main page
Cast:
[Kyle's House]
Kyle: I just got the new Joe Moreira BJJ tape
set.
Kyle: Brazilians are coooool!
[2 minute opening concludes and Moreria starts to teach move after move]
[Tape ends and static fills the TV screen, Sparky the dog enters room and
starts to lick Cartman's face] [Voice Over: Stay tuned, to next week's exciting episode of South Park to find out if Joe Moreira is really Kenny McCormick's father] I think you get the idea that it is very, very, hard to understand what Moreira is saying on this tape set. This tape set has spurred several people who had purchased these tapes to write me asking for a rating of intelligibility of the various tape sets. Here it goes. If Kazeka Muniz is a 5 out of 10 here is my "Intelligible Ratings (tm)" measured in "Munizmarks:"
If the person teaching on given tape set has a sub-optimal command of English there have been several approaches that have been taken. Probably the best is to have someone else do the talking. Ruas used this technique on his tape set. Ruas does not say a word on his tape set. The problem with Ruas was the fact that the person who does the talking does not have a clue about the moves. As a result, the descriptions are very Spartan and of little value. Joe, however, decided to do all the talking on these tapes. Huge mistake! It ends up looking like an old Godzilla film where the movement of the actors mouths and the words coming out don't seem to match. I hate to belabor the point but this is the most striking thing about this tape set. It's the first thing I think of when someone asks, "What do you think of the Moreira tapes?" You might counter by saying, "I just buy the tapes for the damn moves anyway, how are the moves? The moves range from pretty good to a complete waste of time. For example, the first Brown Belt tape has a series of moves that assumes that your opponent does not have a clue as to how to hold someone in the side control. Moreira constantly mentions through out the tape set that you have progressed to such and such belt and your opponent has gotten smarter too. For the most part the moves do progress as the tape set moves along. However, on this tape he drops the ball. I dream of finding opponents who haven't even spent more than a couple of weeks on the mat. I know for a fact that Moreira's brown belt's do know how to hold someone in the side control. On the second Brown Belt tape you will learn how to stand-up properly. God, I hope Joe doesn't wait until Brown Belt to teach his student's how to stand-up. Don't bother buying the Brown Belt tapes. The White Belt tapes were not much better. The tapes start with the whole retread of how to fall properly. The tape then moves into forward and back rolls. Most of the material is really better suited for a Judo tape set rather than a BJJ one. In fact about 1/6 of all the tapes is basic judo throws. As you would expect, this being a white belt oriented tape, most of this is just a rehash of what is on most other tape sets out there. The tape has a screen announcing that it contains "Advanced Guard and Mount Ground Fighting Techniques." The Blue Belt tape is called "Intermediate Guard and Mount Groundfighting Techniques." At this rate of regression you might expect the Black Belt tape to be entitled "Counters to earthworm sneak attacks." However, these are the tapes in which Moreira is the most intelligible. This is because Joe has someone demonstrate the moves on the tapes while he explains. Joe's heavy accent is exacerbated on most of the other tapes when he exerts himself while demonstrating the moves. That being said, worth getting are the both Blue Belt tapes. This is Moreira at his best. The one thing that I liked most about the tape set is the fact that Moreira tries to string the moves together (Move, counter, move, etc). Many tape sets don't make any attempt to do this. Moreira sometimes strings 6-7 moves together. Probably the best example that comes to mind is how he strung the moves together when talking about controlling someone who is in your open guard. The moves, for the most part, were not new, but the linking them together was nice to see. The Black Belt tapes are OK. I literally had a hard time watching them because I kept falling asleep, thus the reference in the South Park skit. The last thing in the world I need is Moreira teaching me Judo throws and counters. You could be better served with other tape sets. I think the thing that puts me to sleep is the fact that Panther in an effort to increase the length of their tapes likes to show some moves 6 times in slow motion. I'm getting sleepy just thinking about it. The purple belt tapes might be worth a look. Tape 1 deals with a lot of defensive stuff and how to pass the guard. Tape 2 has a pretty good discussion of how to pass the open guard. I do recommend getting this tape for this discussion. Most of this is not on other tape sets.
Bottom line: Moreira's tape set is a mixed bag of stuff. Most of the moves you will find on other tape sets. However, what Joe adds to the equation is the structure around the moves. He does a pretty good job of linking the moves together. If you can deal with the fact that the tapes are not in English, but instead are in Gibberish, there are several of the tapes that are worth getting. Bill Lewis BJJ33@aol.com © Copyright Bill Lewis 1998 all rights reserved. |
|||||||||||